Quick answer
Which is better, PrivateS3 or Cloudflare R2?
PrivateS3 is the better pick for backups and archives that are stored more than read. It costs $5.40 per TB a month against $15 at Cloudflare R2, with no request fees. R2 is the better pick for files served to the public. Its egress is free with no cap, and it sits on Cloudflare's CDN (read 17 November 2026).
In brief
- Storage: PrivateS3 $5.40 per TB-month on monthly plans; R2 Standard $0.015 per GB-month, or $15 per TB.
- Requests: R2 bills $4.50 per million Class A and $0.36 per million Class B operations past a free allowance. PrivateS3 bills none.
- Egress: free with no cap at R2. Included up to 3 times the plan at PrivateS3, then slowed, never billed.
- Where R2 leads: public delivery, Workers, a free 10 GB tier and bucket locks set by the customer.
How do PrivateS3 and Cloudflare R2 compare, line by line?
Cloudflare facts come from the R2 pricing page and the R2 bucket locks documentation, both read on 17 November 2026.
| Criterion | PrivateS3 | Cloudflare R2 | Cloudflare source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 TB for 1 month | $5.40 | $15.00 (Standard) | developers.cloudflare.com/r2/pricing, 17 Nov 2026 |
| 10 TB for 1 month | $54 | $150.00 | Calculated from the pricing page |
| 50 TB for 1 month | $270 | $750.00 | Calculated from the pricing page |
| 1 TB for 12 months | $26.77, paid once (12-month plan) | $180.00 (12 × $15) | Calculated from the pricing page |
| Cheaper class | None | Infrequent Access $0.01 per GB-month, 30-day minimum, $0.01 per GB retrieval | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Write and list operations | No fee | Class A $4.50 per million | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Read operations | No fee | Class B $0.36 per million | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Egress | Up to 3 × the plan size, then slowed to 100 Mbit/s, never billed | Free | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Free tier | None | 10 GB-month, 1 million Class A and 10 million Class B operations a month | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Immutability | Object Lock on request by support ticket | Bucket locks: rules that block delete and overwrite for a period or indefinitely | developers.cloudflare.com/r2/buckets/bucket-locks, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Payment | Crypto only: BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR; no ID | Not stated on the pricing page | Pricing page, 17 Nov 2026 |
Prices checked on
Prices exclude VAT; R2 figures use 1 TB = 1,000 GB. PrivateS3's $2.23 per TB-month exists only on 12-month plans.
Which costs less for a backup?
For backups, PrivateS3 costs less at every size: $54 for 10 TB against $150.00 at R2. A backup is written often and read rarely. That is where R2's per-GB storage price and Class A fees weigh most.
According to PrivateS3's survey of 17 November 2026, R2 Standard stored data at $15 per TB. That was the highest rate among the sellers with free egress. Only DigitalOcean Spaces and Amazon S3 Standard cost more per TB. The price index lists all nine.
R2's Infrequent Access class lowers storage to $10 per TB. It adds a 30-day minimum and $0.01 per GB on every retrieval, so a full 10 TB restore would add $100.
When is Cloudflare R2 the better deal?
R2 wins when data is downloaded many times its own size, because its egress has no cap. A 1 TB bucket that serves 20 TB of downloads a month still costs about $15 plus operations at R2.
PrivateS3's rule: Download traffic included up to 3 times the plan size each month; above that, download speed is limited to 100 Mbit/s until the next month, never billed. At 100 Mbit/s, a bucket still moves about 1 TB a day. That suits a restore, not a busy public download site. PrivateS3 also lacks some delivery features: No S3 Select, no bucket website hosting, no event notifications, no IAM policies beyond one key pair per bucket.
R2 also fits apps that already run on Cloudflare Workers and its CDN, and tests that fit in the free 10 GB. The egress explainer compares download rules across sellers.
Where else does R2 do better?
R2 wins on self-service, immutability and network reach.
- Bucket locks set by the customer, by prefix, age or date. PrivateS3's rule: Object Lock (immutable backups) is set on a new bucket on request through a support ticket.
- Global network. R2 serves through Cloudflare's network. PrivateS3 has one site: One data center in the European Union; the city is shown on the order page once the owner confirms it.
- A cheaper class for data read less than once a month.
PrivateS3 also asks for a short wait after payment: One access key and secret key per bucket, created by a person within 24 hours of the order and shown in the client area.
What does PrivateS3 add for private backups?
PrivateS3 sells fixed plans paid in crypto with no ID, and the plan price is the whole bill. It takes 7 coins: BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR. An account number is the login; email is optional. The plan size is a hard quota: an upload that would pass it is refused with a QuotaExceeded error, nothing is billed on top.
Privacy comes from encryption on your side. Without client-side encryption, the operator can technically read stored files, file names and sizes; with it, the operator sees only encrypted blobs, their sizes and upload times. restic, Kopia, rclone crypt and Cryptomator encrypt before upload; the key never leaves your machine, and losing it loses the data. Request logs (source IP, time, bucket, operation, bytes) are kept 14 days for abuse handling and quota accounting, then deleted.
For a full setup with rclone, see the rclone page. Other options sit on the R2 alternatives page.
PrivateS3 vs Cloudflare R2: common questions
Is PrivateS3 cheaper than Cloudflare R2?
For storage, yes: $5.40 a month for 1 TB against $15 at R2 Standard, read on 17 November 2026. For heavy public downloads, R2's free egress with no cap can make it the cheaper choice.
Does Cloudflare R2 charge for egress?
No. R2's pricing page lists egress as free. It bills storage and operations: $4.50 per million Class A and $0.36 per million Class B on Standard.
Does PrivateS3 charge for API requests?
No. No fee for API requests, uploads, deletions or early deletion; no minimum storage duration; no minimum object size.
Can I make backups immutable on both?
R2 offers bucket locks set by the customer. PrivateS3's rule: Object Lock (immutable backups) is set on a new bucket on request through a support ticket.
Can I host a website from either bucket?
R2 serves public content through Cloudflare. PrivateS3 does not host websites: No S3 Select, no bucket website hosting, no event notifications, no IAM policies beyond one key pair per bucket.
Verdict
- Pick PrivateS3 for backups and archives paid in crypto: $5.40 per TB-month and no request fees.
- Pick Cloudflare R2 to serve files to the public, for downloads many times the stored size or for Workers apps.
Sources (3)
- R2 pricing developers.cloudflare.com/r2/pricing — Cloudflare (read 2026-11-17)
- R2 bucket locks developers.cloudflare.com/r2/buckets/bucket-locks — Cloudflare (read 2026-11-17)
- PrivateS3 object storage price index — PrivateS3 (2026-11-17)
5 TB for 12 months: $133.87
No request fees, egress up to 15 TB a month. Pay in BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR.