Quick answer
Which is better, PrivateS3 or Amazon S3?
PrivateS3 is the better pick for backups that only need the core S3 calls. It costs $5.40 per TB a month against $23 for S3 Standard, with downloads up to 3 times the plan included. Amazon S3 is the better pick for IAM policies, storage classes, many regions and apps that run inside AWS (read 17 November 2026).
In brief
- Storage: S3 Standard costs $0.023 per GB-month for the first 50 TB in US East. PrivateS3 costs $5.40 per TB-month on monthly plans, 76.5% less.
- Egress: S3 bills $0.09 per GB after the first 100 GB a month. PrivateS3 includes up to 3 times the plan size and never bills downloads.
- Requests: S3 bills $0.005 per 1,000 writes and lists, $0.0004 per 1,000 reads. PrivateS3 bills none.
- Where S3 leads: IAM, Object Lock, archive classes, replication across regions and event notifications.
How do PrivateS3 and Amazon S3 compare, line by line?
AWS facts come from the S3 pricing page and two AWS price list files, for US East (N. Virginia). The S3 file was published on 16 November 2026, the data transfer file on 17 November.
| Criterion | PrivateS3 | Amazon S3 Standard | AWS source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 TB for 1 month | $5.40 | $23.00 | AWS S3 price list, 16 Nov 2026 |
| 10 TB for 1 month | $54 | $230.00 | Calculated from the price list |
| 100 TB for 1 month | $540 | $2,250.00 (50 TB at $23, 50 TB at $22) | Calculated from the price list |
| 10 TB stored, 10 TB downloaded | $54 | $1,121.00 ($230 + 9,900 GB × $0.09) | Calculated from both price lists |
| Egress to the internet | Up to 3 × the plan size, then slowed to 100 Mbit/s, never billed | 100 GB free, then $0.09, $0.085, $0.07, $0.05 per GB by tier | AWS data transfer price list, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Write and list requests | No fee | $0.005 per 1,000 | AWS S3 price list, 16 Nov 2026 |
| Read requests | No fee | $0.0004 per 1,000 | AWS S3 price list, 16 Nov 2026 |
| Access control | One key pair per bucket | IAM and bucket policies | aws.amazon.com/s3/features, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Regions | One EU data center, not replicated | Many regions; replication to other regions | aws.amazon.com/s3/features, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Object Lock and classes | Object Lock by ticket; one class | Object Lock; several storage classes, including S3 Glacier Deep Archive | aws.amazon.com/s3/features, 17 Nov 2026 |
| Payment | Crypto only: BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR; no ID | Not read in the survey | - |
Prices checked on
Prices exclude tax; 1 TB = 1,000 GB. PrivateS3's $2.23 per TB-month exists only on 12-month plans.
How much does moving a backup off S3 save?
Moving a backup from S3 Standard to PrivateS3 cuts storage by 76.5% and removes download and request fees. Ten TB cost $230.00 a month at S3 Standard and $54 at PrivateS3.
Restores change the picture most. According to PrivateS3's survey of 17 November 2026, a full 10 TB restore from S3 to the internet costs $891.00 in egress alone. At PrivateS3, the same restore fits within the plan: Download traffic included up to 3 times the plan size each month; above that, download speed is limited to 100 Mbit/s until the next month, never billed.
The cost guide works out three bills with storage, downloads and requests for S3 and seven other sellers.
What S3 features does PrivateS3 support?
PrivateS3 supports the calls that backup and sync tools use, not the whole AWS feature set. Supported: The S3 API calls that backup tools use: PUT, GET, HEAD, LIST (v1 and v2), DELETE, multipart upload, presigned URLs, bucket versioning and lifecycle rules.
Missing: No S3 Select, no bucket website hosting, no event notifications, no IAM policies beyond one key pair per bucket. Check your tool against that list before you move. restic, rclone, Kopia, Veeam and Cyberduck need only the supported calls. The S3 API explainer shows which call does what.
One more limit: Erasure-coded across disks and servers in one data center; not copied to a second region, so a second copy elsewhere is advised for data that cannot be lost.
Where does Amazon S3 do better?
S3 wins on control, choice and integration.
- IAM policies for many users and roles on one bucket. PrivateS3 gives one key pair per bucket.
- Storage classes, including archive classes for data almost never read. PrivateS3 has one class.
- Object Lock set by the customer. PrivateS3's rule: Object Lock (immutable backups) is set on a new bucket on request through a support ticket.
- Many regions and apps running next to the data inside AWS.
- Self-service. PrivateS3's rule: One access key and secret key per bucket, created by a person within 24 hours of the order and shown in the client area.
For app data used by AWS services, S3 is often the right home. For the backup copy, it is the most costly seller in PrivateS3's survey. The S3 alternatives page compares five other sellers.
How do you move a bucket from S3 to PrivateS3?
Copy it with rclone, then point your backup tool at the new endpoint. Set one remote for AWS and one for PrivateS3, then run a sync. The endpoint and region are shown with the keys in the client area; the block below uses example values.
The copy itself is billed by AWS as egress, at the rates in the table above. Plan the move once and budget for it. Without client-side encryption, the operator can technically read stored files, file names and sizes; with it, the operator sees only encrypted blobs, their sizes and upload times. A restic repository stays encrypted when copied as is.
[aws]
type = s3
provider = AWS
access_key_id = AWS_ACCESS_KEY
secret_access_key = AWS_SECRET_KEY
region = us-east-1
[privates3]
type = s3
provider = Other
access_key_id = ACCESS_KEY
secret_access_key = SECRET_KEY
endpoint = https://s3.privates3.com
region = eu-central-1
# then run:
# rclone sync aws:BUCKET privates3:BUCKET --progressPrivateS3 vs Amazon S3: common questions
How much cheaper is PrivateS3 than S3 Standard?
76.5% on storage: $5.40 a month for 1 TB against $23.00 in US East, read on 17 November 2026. Downloads and requests add nothing at PrivateS3.
What does S3 charge for downloads?
The first 100 GB a month are free. Then $0.09 per GB for the first 10 TB and $0.085 for the next 40 TB. After that, $0.07 for the next 100 TB and $0.05 above 150 TB.
Will my S3 tools work with PrivateS3?
Tools that use the core calls will: restic, rclone, Kopia, Veeam, Cyberduck and the AWS CLI with an endpoint flag. Features like IAM policies and event notifications are not available.
Does PrivateS3 have Glacier-style archive classes?
No. PrivateS3 has one hot class at one price. Amazon S3 offers several classes, including archive classes for rarely read data.
Is moving off S3 free?
No. AWS bills the egress of the copy at its usual rates. Writing into PrivateS3 costs nothing extra.
Verdict
- Pick PrivateS3 for the backup copy: 76.5% less per TB than S3 Standard, with downloads and requests included.
- Pick Amazon S3 for IAM, archive classes, many regions or data used by apps inside AWS.
Sources (6)
- Amazon S3 pricing aws.amazon.com/s3/pricing — Amazon Web Services (read 2026-11-17)
- AWS price list file, Amazon S3 — Amazon Web Services (published 2026-11-16)
- AWS price list file, data transfer — Amazon Web Services (published 2026-11-17)
- Amazon S3 features aws.amazon.com/s3/features — Amazon Web Services (read 2026-11-17)
- rclone S3 backend documentation — rclone (read 2026-11-17)
- PrivateS3 object storage price index — PrivateS3 (2026-11-17)
5 TB for 12 months: $133.87
No egress bill, no request fees. Pay in BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR.